Joyful Assignment for the Next President: Formulation of a Unified National Energy Policy

By his own admission, a certain former President wasAnd then there is nuclear. I had thought to myself,
not keen on “the vision thing” as a generalyears ago when Shoreham was shut down, that a
proposition. He never did get around to proposing aterrible mistake had just been made, that we were
Unified National Energy Policy. The successorgoing in reverse, and that we would come to rue the
co-Presidency brought forth many initiatives, but aday. That is not to say that “Shoreham”
Unified National Energy Policy was not one of them.was the right installation in the right place, because it
Iteration II of the “no vision thing” has doneprobably wasn’t - only that the mob-like,
no better in this regard.frenzied reaction to its construction evoked an
Apparently the next Presidency is to be neither aanimalistic, irrational streak in human nature which has
Restoration nor a Continuation, which is probably a netbeen seen before over the centuries, and will no doubt
positive. The prospect of a breath of fresh air carriesbe seen again.
with it a certain appeal. Whoever is elected PresidentRather than “shutting down Shoreham”
next autumn has a great opportunity to bring forth aand stopping in its tracks the development of
unified national energy plan. It is indeed very late in thenuclear-powered electricity generating plants
day, but it ought to be one of the entries at the verynationwide, we should instead have been proceeding
top of the Priority List.apace with constructing those plants and building up a
So very much time has been wasted. It can’turanium fuel reserve at the same time, especially since
be recaptured. The current thrashing-about for auranium is available in reasonable abundance right here
“windfall profits tax” on Big Oil may be aat home. Canada has a pound or two of it too, we
reflection of a peculiarly human instinct to inflicthear.
punishment. There is a certain vengefulness about it all,Cursory reading reveals that good strides are now
with overtones of envy, jealousy, and coveting thybeing made in solar generation of electricity. Surely, as
neighbor’s goods. Certainly, there is great painthe technology advances, solar will become an
involved in having to pay a small fortune to fill the gasever-more-important part of the entire electricity
tank, but there would seem not to be very great profitpicture.
in the retail side of the business, for otherwise ExxonThe whole concept of deriving ethanol from corn has
Mobil would not be exiting therefrom, as has beenturned out badly. I never understood the supposed
reported this morning. XOM concluded that thelogic of it. The entire enterprise is one gigantic
availability of gasoline on the retail premises hasboondoggle at the taxpayers’ expense, and it
become the loss-leader or zero-profitrobs the world of food at exactly a time when it is
“bait” in order to bring the customer intomost needed. I foresee that ethanol can become an
the store in order to pay for the gas and then sell himimportant fuel for cars and trucks, as it has in Brazil; but
pretzels and hot coffee at good markups, which afterit ought not be made in great volume from food grains.
all is not really its chosen line of work.It is difficult to transport in bulk, as compared to
I lived on Long Island, New York, from birth until just agasoline, partly because of its corrosive properties; but
few years ago. I clearly remember the drumbeat ofin dilute form and in small package units it is widely
opposition to the proposed nuclear energy plant atavailable and is easily carried about. (see: research
Shoreham, which was actually fueled and ready tocategories “beer” and “Jack
begin producing electricity when the naysayers finallyDaniels”).
prevailed and the plant was shut down before it everLiquefied natural gas is a bit of a puzzle. It’s
earned its first dollar. The memories of Chernobyl anddevilish to handle; it’s dangerous; if it comes
of the close shave at Three Mile Island were fresh infrom overseas, that adversely affects the balance of
the mind. The costs involved in building Shoreham andpayments and does little if anything to promote our
then decommissioning it were inevitablyenergy independence. LNG may be and remain in the
“administered” to customers at the retailmix, but I doubt that it has the potential of becoming a
level, who continue to pay for it to this very day.major part of the solution.
France (perhaps unexpectedly, France?) generatesI recall having a conversation some years ago with a
about 40% of its national electricity usage at its nuclearvery book-learned man of academe. His main theme
generating plants. It is a world leader in the design andcentered upon the necessity to mandate the
construction supervision of state-of-the-art nuclearmanufacture of automobiles in such manner that they
power facilities. Other European countries, by contrast,would operate on stored electricity (batteries) only
reflexively stopped new atomic electricity generation– i.e., without petroleum-derived fuel whatsoever.
cold. Now chickens are coming home to roost, with aRecharging of the batteries would be accomplished by
newly invigorated Gazprom holding all of the facethe use of electrical outlets at home and at
cards, possessing the power (and perhaps theuniversally-available “filling” stations. My
willfulness) to have its way with Europe in terms of theresponse was that it was a marvelous idea; but I
availability and the cost of natural gas.gently inquired what he envisioned to be the fuel which
It may be that we in the United States have tapped allwould be used in order to generate all that electricity.
of our practical sources of hydroelectric power. AndThe question stumped him cold.
yet – one wonders about that, upon seeingThere are not going to be any easy answers; and
pictures of vast acreage of farmland and entirethey are not going to be provided by people whose
Midwestern cities inundated with flood water –lives are centered upon the concept of
all of it doing damage, and none of it generating a“No,” “Never,” or “Not
single kilowatt of power on its determined way to theIn My Back Yard.” Many folks will be unhappy,
Mississippi River and the Gulf of Mexico, loaded withmaybe including me. There may even be more drilling in
valuable topsoil to build up the Delta. What a waste.Alaska, wind farms in the sea within sight of Nantucket
Is there no reasonable way to capture the inherentor even (!) Hyannis, and oil rigs offshore Palm Beach.
generative power of much of that wasted waterHowever, if the professional naysayers would prefer
– and prevent massive property damage andto remain mobile, warm in winter and cool in summer,
disruption of lives while doing so?and continue to see Pat and Vanna appear on the TV
Is there latent hydroelectric generative power availablescreen when they click the “On” button,
to be harnessed in northern Canada, which by mutualthere may have to be some tradeoffs.
agreement might be developed?Every actual or potential source of electrical energy
We are told that the United States still has veryshould be on the new President’s desk for
substantial reserves of soft coal in the ground.discussion. He has the opportunity to get off to a good
Granted, coal is polluting, and utilities consider it to bestart by gathering around him the best advice he can
the “fallback fuel.” (We read that they arefind; and thereupon, for the first time, formulate a
falling back on it now, at least to some extent, in viewUnified National Energy Policy, to be presented to the
of the prices of fuel oil and of natural gas). It wouldCongress and intended to be in place by the end of his
seem that coal will necessarily be a major part of thefirst year in office. It should include specific goals for
electricity-generation equation for decades to come,each actual and potential source of electrical power,
like it or not.together with targets for the substitution of alternate
Then there is wind power, which is still tiny, but growing.fuels in place of gasoline, Diesel fuel, home heating oil,
Denmark generates a very large percentage of itsand jet fuel.
total electricity by wind power. It’s a smallMy Dad taught me a long time ago that there are only
country, to be sure, but it’s leading the way andtwo steps involved in getting a job done: 1) Start, and
showing us what can be done.2) Keep Going.
Generation of electricity by tidal action or by waveOn his very first day in office, the new President
action is in the picture. Those concepts are appealingshould start work on development of a Unified National
because the source of power never goes away.Energy Policy. And then he should Keep Going when
They do seem to be a long distance from becomingthe brickbats begin to fly.
real on any substantial scale.