Challenging the Candidate With Unconventional Questions in a Job Interview

I've been doing a lot of job interviews lately. Evidently,What books have you read lately?
the market being flooded with applicants is one of theAKA, are you willing to learn? The question is about
side effects of the crisis. My organization, instead ofbooks. Internet, TV ads and Vogue don't count (they
laying people off has been steadily hiring and this is duewill tell you something about that person's personality,
to the high turnover rate of the industry.though). If the person likes reading it will open you a
As any other organization, we have a "hiring protocol"huge window into their worlds. This is a big source of
to follow. I'm not going to get into the details of it sinceinformation. And way better than asking about hobbies.
it is not relevant to the purposes of this article. My roleIf you didn't have any financial obligations, what would
in this process is as a hiring manager. Due to theyou be doing with your time?
particularities of the process I only get to interview theAKA, are you a couch potato? Some people will tell
applicant once. This means I only have approximatelyyou: "I'd travel the world for the rest of my life or I'd
one hour to make an assessment and give the goopen a bar on the beach in Maldives". There's nothing
no-go.bad with this, only that it may not be the wingman you
I divide the interview in two parts. The first one is theare looking for.
mandatory Behavioral Interview Questionnaire. DuringIf the CEO or someone very senior in the organization
the second one, I've been given wings to conduct thecomes to you with an urgent problem, how would you
interview at will. I always plan some of my questions inhandle it?
advance with the information I gather from theHow fast are you when the house's on fire? This
person's resume and paperwork.question investigates if a person is able to make
The interviews I have been doing were conducted todecisions on the fly and through the right channels. For
fill a specific position, which led me to become a lotinstance, some might prefer someone that if asked to
more structured in the way I carried them out. Ido something for a big boss would first run it through
acknowledge that some of the questions I've beenyou. Others might prefer a proactive asset that could
using have triggered cliché answers. Boring, mulled,provide a solution without losing time (CEOs are
rehearsed and artificially flavored ones. So I thought,always in a hurry).
"maybe I'm asking too many cliché questions".How long will it take before you make a positive
Another issue is that given the limited time to assessimpact?
the fitness of a candidate, (or the fitness of theThis is one of my favorites. It usually takes 30 days to
position for that particular person) at the end of thelearn the environment and from three to six months to
interview I ended up with a lot of useless or shallowlearn the job and be up to speed. Of course times
information left me with very few worthwhile variablesvary depending on the job. Here you'll also be
from which to base my conclusions.assessing self confidence and the image of self that
The goal is to always challenge the candidate. Put himthe applicant has.
through stressful situations to test his structuralWhat makes you think you had anything to do with
sturdiness, then let him relax with an "easy" or "filler"that achievement?
question to then again make him fall and see how heReality check. Your resume says fantastic things
gets his stuff together again. This speaks a lot aboutabout you, now, how involved were you in this? Can
how the person reacts to not only stressful situations,you articulate the steps that made you an important
but also to dynamically evaluate how his mind works.part in this accomplishment?
But yet again, without useful responses the decisionWhat are your weaknesses and some of your
you make might not be the best one. That's why I didfailures?
some research and put together a list ofWhen you ask the typical question about strengths
unconventional (some funny) questions to mix and stirand weaknesses, point to specific scenarios where
into your job interview.the person failed. This will give you a glimpse of how
Why have you been out of work for an extendedthe applicant deals with failure, how it affects his/her
period of time?morale, and how he prevented a reoccurrence.
If the person you have in front of you has beenHow many people were on your team, and how many
"chilling" for the past couple of years/months, he or shewere laid off?
would better have a good answer for this one.This one lets you know how well or bad positioned
A year from now, what is going to keep you at thiswas that person in the team. And the follow up
company?question,
This one is particularly a good one in high turnoverWhy do you think you were selected for the reduction
environments. But before making this question, youin force?
need to make sure that the person fully understandsThis one can trigger a wide array of answers. From
the job he's looking forward to take. It will also help youthe plain "I don't know" to a twenty minute rant about
give him information about the job that he is not takingthe former employer. This answer usually doesn't look
into account. Truth be told, there are not many jobsgood unless the person has a darn good argument to
where an applicant is absolutely sure of what he issupport his position.
getting into, unless he worked that position before or ifAnd last but not least,
the tasks involved in the job are simple or well knownIf you could be a super hero, which one would you be?
(ie. Telemarketer). This is not the usual "how do youThis one digs deep into the unconscious. It will allow
see yourself in X years" (a friend of mine onceyou to see the person's ideals, what he stands for, his
answered "sitting right there" pointing at theMO and how he'd like to see himself (how he sees
interviewers chair. FYI, he didn't get the job). It doesn'thimself in some cases).
involve aspirations or desires, it prompts to dig intoAcknowledgements:
what motivates the person and how will that work inThanks to Meridith Levinson and Dean Shutt for the
this particular job.inspiration!